American Rights at Work: February 2005 Case
American Rights at Work: February 2005 Case
So much for free and fair elections. Imagine a country where the voter rolls were intentionally inaccurate, where the government was not allowed to list accurate voter rolls? What would happen. In Washington State, where the Rebublicans have been screaming bloody murder about the accurate lists used to elect Christine Gregoire as Governor, the federal government, under the auspices of the NLRB, just handed down a decision which states that Employers don't have to give accurate lists. 87 names out of a list of around 282 people had incorrect contact information. 87. In an industry, apple packing, where workers don't stick around for long, one would think that most addresses would be correct. Its hard to see how giving 87 wrong addresses wouldn't materially impact the election. Here, the employer hides the ball and the board hides its head in the sand, because its opposed to unions.
On December 16, 2004, nearly seven years after the workers’ vote, the majority of the Board ruled against overturning the election results—despite the list inaccuracies, and despite upholding the Judge’s findings of unfair labor practices by the employer.1 The Board asserted that because the Teamsters had the ability to communicate with at least 90 percent of the employees before the election, there was no reason to overturn the results.
The dissenting member of the Board objected to the majority’s ruling, asserting that the employer’s failure to provide that information “interfered with the purpose behind the [sic] rule of ensuring that all employees are fully informed about the arguments concerning representation.” Indeed, during the months leading up to the election, Washington Fruit and Produce waged a strong anti-union campaign and paid four ‘union-avoidance’ consultants to run the campaign (one earned nearly $200 an hour). The company illegally threatened employees with the loss of their jobs if they voted for the union and told employees that by wearing pro-union apparel they were “cutting their own throats.”2 Yet while employees were getting this heavy-handed message from their employer at work, they could only receive communication from the Teamsters outside of work.
The Board’s acceptance of an inadequate list of workers further tips the playing field in
