Thursday, May 22, 2003

rescued posts from old blog

5 22 2003

Find the Cost of Freedom Buried In the Ground

Today is a morning of strikingly bad news. From yesterday's Washington Post I have learned that Justice (we should rename it, Department Justice is so Orwellian, and such complete bull) is using its powers it gained post-9-11 against people that have nothing--repeat this NOTHING--to do with terrorism. That this might come as a surprise to anyone paying attention is not likely--considering how immigrants have been treated (see Demore v. Kim and North Jersey Media Group v. Ashcroft for striking examples). Nonetheless, for the cheerleader---er newspaper of record in Washington to report this, things must really be getting out of hand. A biief excerpt:

Anti-Terror Power Used Broadly

The Justice Department has used many of the anti-terrorism powers granted in the wake of the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks to pursue defendants for crimes unrelated to terrorism, including drug violations, credit card fraud and bank theft, according to a government accounting released yesterday.

In a 60-page report to the House Judiciary Committee, Justice officials also confirmed for the first time that nearly 50 defendants were secretly detained as material witnesses in connection with the investigation of the Sept. 11 attacks. The government has not previously characterized how many defendants had been held.

- - -

While our 1st, 4th, 5th, 6th, and 8th Amendment rights are steadily eroded in the name of fighting the good fight, we seem to whistle right along to the tune. I am not positioning myself as any sort of self-righteous oracle from on high--indeed when I came into work this morning I was glad to see extra security after yesterday's bizarre happenings in New Haven. And lets not forget I called the terrorist hotline after seeing strange goings-on at 59th Street and Columbus Circle. Nevertheless, I do not like the widespread abrogation of rights--one must ask over and again, if the price of maintaining a democracy is ceding the fundamental rights of democratic existence, what in the hell are we struggling against? Vigilence against terror must be coupled with vigilence against the needless circumscription of rights. Once given up, such rights are not likely to be easily wrested back.

5 23 2003

Make the World Go Away, And Get It Off My Shoulders

So now, in a move that strikes me as akin to the post-apocolyptic scenes in the Terminator movies, we are considering using drones to patrol the borders. Drones, the San Franciso Gate tells us can carry spy cameras, sensors, communication equipment or MISSILES. I assume the military will be running this little show. Whatever happened to the Posse Comitatus Act? For that matter, what happened to privacy rights? I imagine once introduced such technology will be used in more places than just the border. Two interesting things in this article: 1) discussion about how these pieces of technology helped oversee the "rescue" of Jessica Lynch. Notice the big lie about the circumstances of Ms. Lynch's retrieval by the US Army continues unabated. 2) The article states, without attribution, that "Support has grown for the unmanned aircraft since their success during the conflicts in Iraq and Afghanistan." Who are these supporters, is what I would ask? If this was the Oakland press, I would guess it was the Athletics. An excerpt follows:

Ridge says unmanned drones could be patrolling borders by end of the year

Unmanned aerial drones similar to ones used in the war on Iraq could be patrolling the U.S. border by the end of the year to help stem illegal immigration and increase security, Homeland Security Secretary Tom Ridge said Thursday.

"We are very serious in looking at UAV (unmanned aerial vehicles) for both border applications, land and sea," Ridge told the House Select Committee on Homeland Security.

Predators and other remote-controlled aircraft can watch over a potential target and fly for hundreds of miles with cameras, sensors, communications equipment or missiles.

Support has grown for the unmanned aircraft since their success during the conflicts in Iraq and Afghanistan.

Spy cameras aboard a drone allowed U.S. commanders to watch the capture of Palestinian hijacking suspect Abul Abbas and oversee the rescue of Army prisoner-of-war Pfc. Jessica Lynch. They also foiled an Iraqi ambush on U.S. and British troops. In November, an unmanned Predator drone killed suspected al-Qaida operatives in Yemen.

5 24 2003

The Truth is Out Of Style (with apologies to MC 900 ft. Jesus)

Truthout.com reported today that Dick Lugar, senior Senate Republican of Indiana, is not too pleased with Dubyah's handling of the post-war era in Iraq. Lugar, I was taught back in my undergraduate polisci days, fancies himself an expert on foreign policy. If I recall correctly, he brokered the deal that removed Ferdinand Marcos' regime from power, when he headed the Senate Foreign Relations Cmte. back in the late 1980s. My grudging respect for Lugar has become less grudging (and more respectful) as a result of reading Truthout's reportage of the Op-Ed piece Lugar penned for yesterday's Post. An excerpt follows:

The most senior Republican authority on foreign relations in Congress has warned President Bush that the United States is on the brink of catastrophe in Iraq.

Richard Lugar, chairman of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, said that Washington was in danger of creating “an incubator for terrorist cells and activity” unless it increased the scope and cost of its reconstruction efforts. He said that more troops, billions more dollars and a longer commitment were needed if the US were not to throw away the peace.

Mr Lugar’s warning came as it emerged that the CIA has launched a review of its pre-war intelligence on Iraq to check if the US exaggerated the threats posed by Saddam Hussein’s weapons of mass destruction. The review is intended to determine if the Pentagon manipulated the assessment of intelligence material for political ends.

Democrats have begun to say that the US is in danger of jeopardising the success of the military action in Iraq, but Mr Lugar is by far the most senior Republican to break ranks with the White House over the issue. Mr Lugar, a moderate who expressed initial reservations about the war, said that the Govevrnment’s planning for post-war Iraq had clearly been inadequate.

“I am concerned that the Bush Administration and Congress have not yet faced up to the true size of the task that lies ahead, or prepared the American people for it,” he said, writing in The Washington Post. Mr Bush should state clearly “that we are engaged in ‘nation-building’,” he said, a statement that would require the President to swallow one of his tenets of the 2000 election campaign.

Speaking derisively of President Clinton’s foreign policy, Mr Bush said it was not the role of US troops to nation-build.

Mr Lugar also took a swipe at Mr Bush’s victory speech on the USS Abraham Lincoln earlier this month, delivered under a banner that read: “Mission Accomplished”. He said: “President Bush should make clear to one and all that he will declare ‘Mission Accomplished’ in Iraq not on the basis of our military victory or the date of our withdrawal, but on what kind of country we leave behind.”

What can one say about this, but geezus h. fricking begeezus?

The Courier Mail: US plans death camp [ 26may03 ] US plans death camp

27 may 03

THE US has floated plans to turn Guantanamo Bay into a death camp, with its own death row and execution chamber.

Prisoners would be tried, convicted and executed without leaving its boundaries, without a jury and without right of appeal, The Mail on Sunday newspaper reported yesterday.

The plans were revealed by Major-General Geoffrey Miller, who is in charge of 680 suspects from 43 countries, including two Australians.

The suspects have been held at Camp Delta on Cuba without charge for 18 months.

General Miller said building a death row was one plan. Another was to have a permanent jail, with possibly an execution chamber.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

5/29/2003

I Feel Like Some Old Engine--I Lost My Driving Wheel

Justice Takes a Beating

I woke up this morning to this tidbit. While I am slaving away to write these grade memos on constitutional law, the constitution is being yanked out from under us. The voice of reason in Black v. Virginia returns to form, in his decision in a striking defeat for the prevention of the use of torture in interrogation, let alone the prevention of self-incrimination. I think I am going to change my name to Doug Mackenzie and move to Canada, post haste. An excerpt of the LA Times editorial--a la truthout--follows.

While Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas labored to justify the bullying interrogation of a farm worker whom an Oxnard police officer had just gravely wounded, Justice John Paul Stevens, dissenting, called the inquisition what it was: "the functional equivalent" of torture. Thomas' 6-3 majority opinion Tuesday rolls back decades of constitutional protections against self-incrimination and all but invites the backroom rough-'em-up police tactics of old.

The farm worker, Oliverio Martinez, is blind and partly paralyzed from the five bullets that police pumped into his body after they stopped him in connection with an investigation of possible drug sales in his Oxnard neighborhood. Although Martinez initially complied with orders to dismount from his bicycle, a scuffle resulted when the officers discovered he was carrying a knife and Martinez was shot.

Paramedics arrived and carted away Martinez, bleeding and screaming, to a hospital. For nearly an hour, as Martinez waited for medical treatment and then as doctors tended him, the officers pressured him to confess to starting the fight.

"I am dying!" Martinez cried.

"OK, yes, you are dying," the officer said. "But tell me why you are fighting with the police."

Not once did the police officers inform Martinez of his right to remain silent and to have a lawyer present. Instead, to try to badger him into a confession, they took advantage of his physical agony and mental anguish and the fact that he couldn't move from the hospital bed.

In the end, the officers got nothing useful from Martinez and never charged him with a crime. Martinez sued, both for the shooting and for civil damages on the ground that police violated his 5th Amendment right against self-incrimination and his due process rights against egregious police conduct. The shooting lawsuit still stands.

Writing for a splintered majority, Thomas insisted that where there was no harm of any legal consequence, there was no foul. "Martinez was never made to be a 'witness' against himself in violation of the 5th Amendment's self-incrimination clause because his statements were never admitted as testimony against him in a criminal case [T]he mere use of compulsive questioning, without more, [does not] violate the Constitution." Such a narrow thread of reasoning cuts a wide path to cruelty.

Because Martinez had not been advised of his rights, the court said, had police charged him based on his nearly incoherent statements, his disclosures would not have been admissible as evidence anyway.

Three cases before the court next term could push at the boundaries of permissible evidence in criminal cases. The Martinez case turns back the clock, and the coming cases could multiply the harm to a civilized justice system.